A father of two risked his life by testifying against Mexican drug cartels for the Justice Department. The government deported him three times within weeks, just days after Marco Rubio took steps to remove his protection from torture.
The U.S. government is now deporting people in ways that could make noncitizens think twice before helping federal authorities stop major crimes.
On Friday, U.S. District Judge Stephanie Gallagher ordered the Trump administration to bring back a man who had testified for the Justice Department against people linked to Mexican drug cartels. The government had deported him three times in just a few weeks. One of those times, they sent him to Mexico, even though an immigration judge had already decided he would likely be tortured there.
The Man Was Identified As A Father Of Two
The man, identified in court records only as John Doe and described as a father of two in reporting on the court filing published Sunday, was granted protection in 2024 under the Convention Against Torture after an immigration judge found he would likely be tortured if he was ever returned to Mexico. He had testified for the Justice Department against defendants affiliated with the cartels.
The specific protection he held, a status known as deferral of removal under federal regulations, exists for one narrow purpose. It stops the government from sending someone to the country where a judge has found they would likely face torture. It is not citizenship. It is not a green card. It is a floor, the bare minimum the law provides, and this administration went through it anyway.
According to Gallagher’s memorandum opinion ordering the government to bring Doe back, the removals began in July. Officials first tried to send him to Guatemala. Guatemala refused to accept him and handed him to Mexican officials, who also declined to take him. Then on August 1, the administration deported him to Mexico outright, “without his phone or other personal belongings.”
The opinion also points out something troubling. Acting ICE Director David Venturella and Secretary of State Marco Rubio personally acted to end Doe’s protection just days before he was deported, using a process the court called “extremely rare.” There is no explanation in the record for why such high-level officials got involved in one man’s immigration case.
Kyle Cheney, Politico’s senior legal affairs reporter, flagged the ruling on Sunday.
Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, a former immigration attorney, wrote that Doe risked his life by helping authorities against the cartels, making him “a target for a hideous death if they ever got their hands on him.” Still, the administration deported him to Mexico.
Journalist Christy Somos described a wider pattern of removals under this administration, writing that officials are “just grabbing people and throwing them wherever.”
This Is Becoming A Common Practice For Trump’s Administration
This is not even the only recent case in which a federal court has intervened over the removal of a witness. Last month, a federal judge in Houston barred the government from deporting a witness to the fatal shooting of Lorenzo Salgado Araujo by a federal immigration agent.
None of this is coming from a judge with an axe to grind. Gallagher is a Trump appointee who previously ordered the administration to bring back a Venezuelan man deported to El Salvador in violation of a settlement agreement.
Her order in this case is clear. The government must bring Doe back right away. If he is detained after returning, he must be held within 200 miles of Baltimore. The government also has to file a daily status report until he is back in the U.S.
Donald Trump and Republicans have based their immigration message on the promise of removing dangerous criminals. This case shows the opposite. The government deported a man who risked everything to help federal prosecutors go after real cartel criminals, took away the protection an immigration judge gave him, and sent him to the country where he would likely be tortured.
Every potential witness, informant, or noncitizen thinking about helping American law enforcement will notice what happened here. The message is clear: helping the government can lead to being sent to the very place a judge said you would likely be tortured. This does not make anyone safer. It warns future witnesses that cooperation could cost them their lives.
If you can afford to chip in less than $5/month as an annual supporter you can help us increase our coverage of Trump’s illegal and immortal activities and expose his administration. If you don’t have the means to contribute right now, please consider a free subscription so we can reach as many people as possible with our grassroot campaign! We’d love to continue this week with your support!